This item is available on the Militant Islam Monitor website, at

Wounded Taliban in Quetta Pakistan recuperate in clinic financed by 'Afghan businessman'

November 18, 2006,,2089-2459906,00.html

The Sunday Times

November 19, 2006

Wounded Taliban treated in Pakistan

Tim Albone, Quetta

PAKISTAN is allowing Taliban fighters wounded in battles with British and other Nato forces in Afghanistan to be treated at safe houses.

The Sunday Times found Taliban commanders and their fighters recuperating in the city of Quetta last week and moving freely around parts of the city.

In a white-walled compound in the northern suburb of Pashtunabad, more than 30 Taliban were recovering from the bloodiest fighting in Afghanistan since their regime was ousted five years ago.

Among the most defiant was a young commander who had been shot in the calf last month while fighting British troops in Gereshk, a town in the Afghan province of Helmand, and who had returned to Quetta to be treated. "Fighting the British is as easy as eating a loaf of bread from my hand," he said in a soft voice. "Fighting the British is much easier than the Americans. They have no faith."

The proof that Taliban are using Quetta for rest and recuperation — if not also for training as widely suspected — is embarrassing for President Pervez Musharraf, who is due to receive Tony Blair, the prime minister, today. Musharraf has long denied claims from the Afghan government that his military intelligence is providing support and safe havens for the Taliban.

He was outraged when Hamid Karzai, the Afghan president, went to Islamabad, the Pakistan capital, last February and presented him with a list of names, addresses and telephone numbers in Quetta of Taliban leaders, including Mullah Omar, the head of the movement. Dismissing this as "nonsense", Musharraf accused Karzai of being "totally oblivious of what is happening in his own country".

In New York in September he told the Council on Foreign Relations that Omar had not been in Pakistan since 1995 and was holed up in the Afghan city of Kandahar. "They (the Afghans) have taken a very, very easy course: the scapegoating of Pakistan," he again insisted in a television interview last week.

Drawn by the British, the border between Pakistan and Afghanistan is more than 1,400 miles of largely mountainous terrain that is hard to monitor, largely lying in lawless tribal areas. These border areas were used as bases by the mujaheddin in their fight against the Russian occupation of Afghanistan in the 1980s, and many of the camps and ammunition stores remain.

But there is growing unease in both Washington and Whitehall about how much of the problem is logistical and whose side Pakistan is on. Not a single known Taliban has been arrested in Pakistan apart from a spokesman, Latifullah Hakimi. That came only after British intelligence intercepted his telephone call from Peshawar ordering the execution of a British engineer.

British and American military commanders in Afghanistan are fed up with their men being killed by fighters who slip back across the border where they cannot be followed. General David Richards, the British commander of Nato forces in Afghanistan, flew to Islamabad last month to raise the issue with Musharraf, though he insisted his aim was "co-operation, not confrontation".

The Foreign Office confirmed that concerns about Pakistan's position were among the main reasons for Blair's trip to Islamabad — his third since the September 11 attacks turned Musharraf from a pariah into a key ally.

We fully understand the tightrope that General Musharraf is walking between extremists and helping the West," a spokesman said. "We know he is fighting a number of insurgencies within his own borders. But he too has said he is concerned about growing Talibanisation in his own country and our message is we want to help."

The official expressed frustration at the failure of the Afghan government to produce concrete evidence of Pakistan's alleged training of the Taliban. "They constantly tell us of videos but we never actually get them."

Musharraf's insistence that his country is not a safe haven was undermined, however, by what The Sunday Times saw in an area to which journalists are often denied access.

the safe house in Quetta, the Taliban fighters seemed relaxed, some reading the Koran, others laughing and discussing recent battles. Several regional commanders were present and confirmed they used Quetta to relax and study out of reach of Nato. Although the men said they were regularly "shaken down" by the police, a bribe of as little as £2 usually resolved the issue.

"We find the fighting fun," said one, a 38-year-old man from Zabul who commands forces in southeastern Afghanistan. "Jihad against the infidels is more important than studying books. A weak man should fight for three months of the year and study the rest. A strong man should fight for six months."

Another, who introduced himself by his nom de guerre Mullah Qahramaan (Pashto for hero), said: "When I hear the shout of Allahu Akbar (God is the greatest) at the start of battle, I can't help myself — I just run towards the enemy." He had just returned to Quetta, he said, after six months of fighting in Panjwayi where in September Nato launched its biggest offensive against the Taliban.

Nato claims as many as 1,500 Taliban fighters were killed but this has been disputed by the Taliban. On a visit to the battlefield during its final days, no mass graves or bodies were seen.

"If they (Nato) killed 500 Taliban, they should show a grave for only 50 Taliban and I will believe this figure," said the commander. "But nobody has seen even one grave. We only lost 32 fighters, although they killed a lot of civilians."

Many of the fighters were vitriolic about the British. "We would speak with the British over the radio," said Mullah Samat, a young man with bloodshot eyes and a white turban who said he had been fighting in the town of Musa Qala in northern Helmand where British troops were pinned down in a platoon house. "We would say, ‘Death to the British, death to the infidels,' and they would then say, ‘Death to the Taliban,' back to us."

He claimed he was from a group of 300 fighters and insisted that only 10% were hardcore Taliban, educated in madrasahs in Pakistan, while the rest were villagers disillusioned with the Karzai government.

He denied foreigners were involved and claimed an Afghan businessman supported them by setting up a hospital to treat the fighters. "We are not fighting for money, we are fighting for faith and the future of our country," he said.

"When we saw the British fighting, it was a big shame. They were hiding behind walls." But he added: "I do feel bad, though, that we are killing the British. They are human and I am especially sad for their families . . . they are dying for no reason, just to occupy a country."

This item is available on the Militant Islam Monitor website, at